Schools
to adopt 'phonics' style of teaching reading 
The
education secretary, Ruth Kelly, today announced an overhaul of the way children
are taught to read with a return to a "back to basics" approach. A
teaching style known "synthetic phonics", where children learn the letter sounds
as the building blocks to words, was recommended in a review of the teaching of
reading published today by the former schools inspector Jim Rose. Ms
Kelly immediately adopted the main finding."Phonics
should be central, it is central, but what we are doing is we are accepting Jim
Rose's recommendation that it should be taught first and fast," Ms Kelly told
BBC Radio 4's Today programme. She
also denied accusations that she was adopting Conservative policy after the shadow
education secretary, David Cameron, made the issue part of his election campaign.
Phonics was already
part of the national literacy strategy and today's announcement would only enhance
that, she said. New learning materials to help teachers with the new system will
be in place in schools by September, Ms Kelly said. Phonics
went out of fashion in the 1960s when it was replaced by a system which relies
of children learning whole words - and their meaning - in one go. The
argument against phonics is that while it speeds up the rate that children can
read words, it does not aid their comprehension of what the word means.
The Rose review was triggered by a seven- year study of the teaching of phonics
to 300 children in Clackmannanshire in Scotland. The research put the children
up to three years ahead in reading, but did not show a significant improvement
in comprehension of words. The
report published today also recommended: · That teaching reading through phonics
should be preceded by attention to developing children's speaking and listening
skills; · Systematic, direct teaching of synthetic phonics should be the first
strategy taught to all children learning to read, introduced by the age of five;
· Some children will need more intensive intervention - they should get "catch-up"
support lessons; and · Teaching of phonics should be monitored to maintain standards.
Mr Rose said:
"This review comes at a time when it is widely accepted by practitioners, teachers
and researchers that phonic work is essential though not sufficient in learning
to read and write. Despite this positive consensus about the importance of phonic
work ... there are deeply divided professional views about how phonic work is
best taught."The review
is therefore centred on judging the best way forward from the standpoint of the
learners, that is to say children who are beginner readers and writers." The
shadow education minister Nick Gibb said: "Since the Conservative party were proposing
a synthetic phonics policy during the general election, obviously we welcome Ruth
Kelly's decision to adopt the recommendations of the Rose review."
Edward Davey, the Liberal Democrat education spokesman, said: "Rose has struck
a careful balance, that should give teachers enough leeway to consider each child's
individual needs, after the unfortunate politicisation of this issue. "What should
not go unnoticed is Rose's greater emphasis on the importance of quality teaching,
irrespective of method." Polly
Curtis, education correspondent Thursday December 1, 2005 With
much gratitude to the brilliant 'Gardian
Unlimited' website. 
|